Sunday, July 22, 2012

Faking It


Is there a glut of unqualified ESL/EFL teachers plying the world with their fake or non-existent degrees? And is this rampant fakery limited to the ESL industry, or is it everywhere?

I'm about to start a new job on Monday and they have asked me to bring my degree. Original. Not a copy. Can't work here without producing it.

Same story every time I change jobs or countries, or need a new course or certificate. I guess I'm annoyed because I would much rather be able to hang my degree in its frame, on my wall. I have the perfect spot for it! Instead, my degree lives in a cardboard tube, tightly rolled up and ready to travel whenever I need to prove to the next HR person that I in fact told the truth on my résumé. The default assumption is that I`m lying. Guilty until proven innocent.
It`s ruining the degree. It has been uncurled and re-curled, and manhandled so much that it has developed creases across the surface. The seal is cracked, and the edges are dirty and wrinkled. This might not bother some people, but it really upsets me. My degree is something very personal, and precious to me. I don`t want the whole world handling it every two years and shoving it carelessly back into the tube.

I should be used to this by now, but it still pisses me off every time. Why is it that other people in other industries can hang their degrees on their walls and never have to take them down? My mother has four degrees which have been hanging in their frames for over 20 years. I can guarantee she has never had to take them out for some monkey to photocopy. Two other friends have their multiple degrees hanging in their homes. They have never had to roll them up and stuff them in a tube.

Why does the ESL industry have such a hard time believing that someone who has been working in the industry for 13 years, in various countries, and who has successfully obtained further certification, and who has embarked on a Masters degree in the field would be in possession of a real, bona fide degree? I really want to hear from people in other fields to see if others have to go through this hassle every time they want to cross the street. I don't know anyone else who does.

So who are all these degree-lying people that they think they need to weed out? Do people really apply with faked credentials? Wouldn't a little logic suffice for establishing the veracity of my claim? Let's think about this for a minute. I am certified by TESL Ontario. My registration number is on my résumé. You cannot get certification unless you have shown the degree to the TESL Ontario office (Original. Not a copy). Therefore, if you really really doubted that I have a degree, you COULD search for my registration number on the TESL Ontario website, verify it`s there, and therefore logically deduce that the degree must exist! Then I wouldn`t have to carry the damned thing with me on Monday!

Maybe it`s time to start believing and trusting long-time professionals. I couldn`t have gotten as far as I have if I didn`t have a degree and you know it. Stop wasting my time!

15 comments:

  1. Yes, it's perfunctory to show an original BA when a TESL Ontario certificate is shown instead, same with OCTC for BEds.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. It makes much more sense to carry around the TESL Ontario. It's small....fits in a folder. The degree is HUGE and hassle-inducing. They are not designed for portability. Whoever thought up this brilliant scheme clearly has never laid eyes on an actual degree. If they are required by Languages Canada, or the government of Canada, or TESL Canada, or whatever, then I should be able to have it checked out once and forever, and then they can keep me on record as having done it. Then when I transfer to a different school, they can pull up the file and VOILA!! It's still there!! The same as the LAST TIME I applied for a job!! Jeebus...it's not rocket science!

      Delete
    2. Agreed. What I meant was that in order to have a TESL Canada or TESL Ontario or OCTC, you have to have a university degree, so if you have one of them, then you obviously have a degree too.

      Delete
  2. Official copies of transcripts are required before starting any US teaching or academic library positions that I've seen. Nobody's ever asked to see my actual diploma.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Yes, I think the US is more adept at cutting through the BS. Canadians have to red-tape everything just to feel more important.

      Delete
  3. This comment has been removed by the author.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Thanks Heather!
      It's nice to know that people enjoy reading it. I know it's not everyone's cup of tea. I'm sure I'll be getting back into the swing of things soon, when school starts up again.

      Delete
  4. Maybe employers 1) don't trust TESL Ontario or TESL Canada to have checked properly for degree credentials; or 2) can't be bothered to check the TESL Ontario registry themselves.

    When I started my first job in Toronto, if my employer had checked my degree through TESL Canada, they would have found that I didn't have actually have TESL Canada accreditation. It was an honest mistake on my part: The school where I got my certificate didn't explain accreditation clearly, and I thought my TESL certificate was my TESL Canada accreditation.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. You have a point, not because employers shouldn't trust TESLO or TESLC to have checked properly about degrees--why believe any certificate program about anything they require then?--but because TESLO certificates are so ridiculously simplistic to replicate. In this regard, checking either registry would work, but you're right again, I wouldn't bother doing that. Still, requiring to prove you have a degree (which is relatively unrelated to teaching English as a career) as opposed to requiring proof that you have good TESL training, which is directly related to your career, is an absolutely dumb thing for employers to value.

      Delete
    2. That IS a good point! My degree is a Bachelor of Fine Arts in Visual Art (photography and art history)! Absolutely irrelevant when it comes to teaching! Of far more value to me is my classroom experience, my CELTA, my TESL ON certificate, and my overseas experience!! Any single ONE of those makes me a better teacher than my BFA!!!

      Delete
  5. It was my impression that you don't need a degree to have TESL Canada, but you do for TESL Ontario. I got my CELTA many years ago, and that enabled me to join TESL Canada, but a degree was not part of the requirements (I had one by then anyway). But for TESL Ontario, I had to take the thing downtown to their office and present it to the office dude. My point is that once TESL Ontario has seen it, and they have recorded it, any employer should be able to check my TESL Ontario number which I provide on my resume, and they will know that TESL Ontario has already seen the document. The TESL Ontario website does allow employers to check your number. I'm not sure about TESL Canada, but its requirements are less strict.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. No, you need a university degree for both. http://www.tesl.ca/Assets/TESLCanada/Certification+Descriptors+$!26+Explanations+June+2010.pdf?method=1 (pg. 4)

      Delete
    2. Thanks! I stand corrected.

      Delete
  6. This comment has been removed by the author.

    ReplyDelete
  7. Thanks Heather,
    I do hope to find some time to blog soon. Blogging needs positive energy, and I haven't had much lately. Hope to catch up soon!

    ReplyDelete